Archive of Our Own ^beta

EmptyTome, sophia_sol, Josette_Arnauld, Saathi1013, dar_vidder, storiesfortravellers, sanguinity, heyholmesletsgo, cupidsbow, RevolutionaryJo, periru3, swizzlespoon, sandalwoodbox, thingswithwings, UnhinderedDreams, skripka, noxelementalist, leanwellback, videobaths, giandujakiss, Avengerbunny, Tafadhali, ultraviolet_catastrophe, bironic, FairestCat, Constantly_Oscitating, fenellaevangela, rukbat3, yourlongshadows, platinumvampyr, whoareyouidonteven, JayneL, fabrega, turquoisetumult, notevenyou, citruses, evilmouse, Gileonnen, Luthien, paranoidangel, and thisbluespirit as well as 3 guests left kudos on this work!

1. thisbluespirit Sat 01 Feb 2025 02:24PM UTC

   

   Oh, excellent! You've got the balance of the show/ship between sweetness and morbidity just right. <3

   Comment Actions

   • Thread

2. Luthien Sat 01 Feb 2025 03:51PM UTC

   

   I love your choice of song, and great choice of clips. You've really captured both the feel of the show and the mix of happiness and terrible longing in the vibe between the Piemaker and Chuck. Great stuff.

   Comment Actions

   • Thread

3. evilmouse Sat 01 Feb 2025 07:45PM UTC

   

   I loved this show so much and it was great to revisit this via such a sweet video! Of course the song is perfect of course. Why do they always cancel the most creative things?! I'm still soaking in the sweetness of your creation, thank you.

   Comment Actions

   • Thread

4. citruses Sat 01 Feb 2025 07:58PM UTC

   

   This is beautiful and sad and strange in the best way! When that second “kiss today goodbye…” hit and it was Chuck’s own death I about cried. I loved this weird show so much, thank you for letting me live in some of those feelings again with your wonderful song and editing choices.

   Comment Actions

   • Thread

5. turquoisetumult Sat 01 Feb 2025 09:07PM UTC

   

   Aww, Ned!!! (And Chuck!) I loved your song choice as it resonated well with the show's old-school vibe. This was both sweet and slightly melancholic! You did a nice job with this! ♥ Thank you so much, Festividder!

   Comment Actions

   • Thread

6. FairestCat Sun 02 Feb 2025 01:53PM UTC

   

   This song choice was brilliant.

   Comment Actions

   • Thread

7. Tafadhali Sun 02 Feb 2025 07:13PM UTC

   

   Oh wow!!! This song frames Ned's choice to bring back Chuck in such an interesting way. Love this.

   Comment Actions

   • Thread

8. videobaths Mon 03 Feb 2025 04:31PM UTC

   

   I really, really enjoyed this. I feel like you told a really strong story with this vid.

   Comment Actions

   • Thread

9. periru3 Sat 08 Feb 2025 06:50AM UTC

   

   Oh noooo you really got me right in my Ned feels. "The gift was ours to borrow" as a lyric for him just immediately made me tear up. When I saw your song selection I was honestly kinda like "huh. Love the song, don't know how well it'll work for the source" and as soon as it started I was like "I'm a dummy, this is perfect." I love that it is full of wonderful Ned/Chuck cuteness, but also that it's still really about him and about this crazy gift/curse he has and what he chooses to do with it. Lovely <3

   Comment Actions

   • Thread

10. cupidsbow Sat 08 Feb 2025 06:02PM UTC

    

    I keep thinking that there's no way to make a PD vid fresh, and yet... *waves hands at the adorableness*. Very on point. :)

    Comment Actions

    • Thread