Papaya_Katty
Fandoms
Recent works
-
Tags
Summary
"Something was wrong with the Beasts. And every Ancient was worried for their other half."
The people the Ancients fought in the war with Dark Enchantress against. Had now become some of the most important people to them. But now those people were dying.
Recent bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
Each ruler relies on their jamstone to pick their fated mate, their perfect match, the one who will bring balance and prosperity. Eternal Sugar is having trouble finding her's. Which won't do because at this rate, she's going to fall in love with her bodyguard, Hollyberry.
All beast x ancient mentioned but Eternalberry is the focus.
Bookmarked by Papaya_Katty
13 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
In which Sage of Truth-esque Shadow Milk (not a soul jam holder) finds himself as the Beast of Deceit
Shadow Milk was a ‘normal cookie’; he often found it funny that he shared the same name as a character from a novel he read. Friends and students alike frequently teased him for it. But alas, he was a teacher at heart, and there was no way in his mind that he would torment someone so kind-hearted who believed in the truth.
After all, Pure Vanilla was such a charming character that he was swayed by his lowest and cried at his peaks when he overcame his suffering.
This is why it was distressing to find himself as an astral projection watching over Pure Vanilla in a world where he was still known as “Healer Cookie.”
With a book in his hands, he was given a checklist of requirements. Oh- He was Shadow Milk Cookie, from the novel. Shouldn’t he be given a script? Witches, where would he even begin? He was a performer at heart, but in something so life-like, he might have been given an impossible task.
Please let this be a lie, or a dream. Yes, a dream was better.
Updates weekly.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 274,314
- Chapters:
- 48/?
- Comments:
- 1,448
- Kudos:
- 1,431
- Bookmarks:
- 234
- Hits:
- 50,548
Bookmarked by Papaya_Katty
13 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Everyone knows the Virtues fell from grace and became Beasts. But what if that wasn't the case?
Through a series of bad luck and miscommunications, all the virtues think the others fell and became Beasts.This is a series of one offs giving all pov's from when the virtue's "fell"
Hope you enjoy!
Bookmarked by Papaya_Katty
28 Dec 2025
-
Tags
Summary
The beast escape the tree and elder faerie dies
Bookmarked by Papaya_Katty
19 Dec 2025
-
Tags
Summary
At the cusp of defeat, Shadow Milk gets transported to a backwards world: Dark Enchantress was sealed away before she could do any lasting damage, the Beasts never came to be, and the Ancients rule over an otherwise peaceful world.
Oh, and apparently his counterpart is dead and hailed as a hero. Because his life wasn’t already complicated enough.
OR
What happens when the guy who basically saved all of cookiekind comes back as an evil, corrupted version of himself?
Healing. Healing is what happens…hopefully.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 154,197
- Chapters:
- 18/25
- Comments:
- 1,651
- Kudos:
- 5,369
- Bookmarks:
- 1,013
- Hits:
- 185,795
Bookmarked by Papaya_Katty
09 Dec 2025